Okay so not so great for extra dry, chapped lips because I'm finding myself reapplying like crazy throughout the day but the smell is sweet so it's not so bad. There is a little shine which I like to use over a lip stain as well. I really like the round shape of the ball of balm because I dislike having to use other lib balms that you have to stick your finger in to use. Not the best most hygiene way people who use pots I'm looking at you!