A complete failure - it is impossible to completely wash away makeup smears so that I turn into a panda. But it would still okay, most unpleasant - it stings the eyes and slightly irritating to the skin around the eyes. It looks like some of Garener effect only consistency in the form of water / tonic. Smell is bright and quite specific, not to say that much like the straight. The only plus - a natural, pleasing composition. Well, plus: not tested on animals.